Nosemonkey's EUtopia

In search of a European identity

The Home Office – liars or idiots?

Yesterday: the Home Office is told off for dodgy accounting – “It is disappointing that the Home Office had not maintained proper financial books and records”

Today: the self-same Home Office that can’t keep tabs on its own accounts announces wildly implausible “identity fraud” figures designed to make ID cards look sensible: “At �35 per person, the estimated annual cost was greater than that of planned compulsory national identity cards, [Home Office Minister Andy Burnham] told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.”

Why, precisely, should we pay any attention to any figures the Home Office ever produces?

Update: As if by magic, an analysis of the figures appears

“In fact, the costs to the state of fraudulent identity, where compulsory provision of a card would definitely save money – unpaid fines, police time taken in checking backgrounds, social security fraud etc. runs to a hundred million, maybe two, at best. And plenty of that might be saved if the government tightened its own security procedures, as proven in the tax credit fraud fiasco.”

Go read.

Udate 2: DK goes off on one with a number of pertinent points, while the Hamster and the Longrider also lay in with numbers and such. All good stuff.